A slow, cozy journey to dreamland where your child says goodnight to the whole wide world.
Ages 0-6
From $14.90
Choosing the binding
Hardcover or softcover for a child’s book: the question is usually answered for the wrong book
Why the usual advice about bindings does not apply to a book a four-year-old will actually handle, and the two things that decide it instead.
Search this and you will be told about prestige, resale and cost per unit - all of it true, and all of it about an adult novel or a print run. A child’s book is a different object. It gets opened one-handed with a child on your lap, pulled off a shelf by the top of its spine, carried somewhere it should not go, and either read to pieces or kept for twenty years. Those two futures want different bindings, and the price difference is not what decides it.
What the cover board actually changes
A hardcover is a rigid board with printed paper wrapped round it, glued to the text block as a case. That construction is why it holds its shape on a shelf, why the spine survives being hooked by a small finger, and why it opens flatter - which sounds like a detail until you are reading aloud with one hand free.
A softcover is one heavier sheet scored and glued straight onto the pages, so the whole book flexes together. It is lighter, it goes in a bag, and it wants to close itself. After a few dozen readings the corners round off and the spine creases where it was held open.
Under two, the honest answer is neither
A child who is still mouthing and tearing wants a board book: thick, wipeable, effectively indestructible. We do not make one, and saying so is more useful than selling you a hardcover for a one-year-old and watching it come apart.
If the book is for a baby but the person opening it is an adult - a new-baby gift, a christening, a first Christmas - that is a different job and a hardcover does it well. The book is being kept for later, not handed over now.
A keepsake and a book that gets read are not the same object
This is the actual decision, and almost nobody phrases it. A keepsake is meant to survive the child: it sits on a shelf, it gets taken down at eighteen, it wants a hard case and a spine you can read across a room. A reading copy is meant to be used up, and a softcover that is battered by year three has done its job rather than failed at it.
Parents buying for their own child often want the second and buy the first. People buying as a gift almost always want the first, because a keepsake is what a gift is for - and because they will not be the one carrying it to nursery.
Cost is not the deciding factor here, which is unusual
On an adult hardback the hardcover carries a large premium, and that premium is genuinely what most people are choosing between. On a single personalised book printed to order the two editions sit close together, because the cost is dominated by printing one copy of a book that did not exist this morning rather than by the board on the front.
Which is freeing: you can pick on durability and use rather than on budget. The current prices for both are on the product page, where they are computed rather than written down.
How to decide in one question
Ask who is going to be holding it in three years. If the answer is the child, and often, buy the softcover and accept that it will look loved. If the answer is a parent taking it down off a shelf to show someone, buy the hardcover.
And if you genuinely cannot tell - a gift for a child you do not know well, say - the hardcover is the safer guess, because a keepsake that gets read anyway is fine, and a reading copy that was supposed to be a keepsake is not.
Where to start
See all stories
A reassuring story for the big first day, where your child learns that a brand-new place can quickly start to feel just like home..
Ages 2-8
From $14.90
A joyful celebration story where your child turns another year older, surrounded by wishes, laughter, and a sprinkle of birthday magic..
Ages 0-8
From $14.90
Your child travels back to the age of gentle giants.
Ages 4-8
From $14.90
Common questions
Which one survives a toddler?
The hardcover, by a distance - the rigid case is doing the work, and the spine is the part a small child destroys first. But a toddler who still chews books wants a board book, and neither of our printed editions is one.
Do you make a board book?
No. We print a softcover and a hardcover. For a child under about two who handles books unsupervised, a board book from a bookshop is the right object and we are not it.
Which lies flat for reading aloud?
The hardcover, because the case is hinged away from the text block. A softcover has to be held open, which is the difference between one hand and two when a child is on your lap.
Is the hardcover worth it for a gift?
Usually, yes - not because it is better made in the abstract, but because a gift is nearly always meant to be kept, and the person unwrapping it reads the binding as part of the present. The two are close enough in price here that it is not the sacrifice it would be on an adult hardback.
Can I see the book before choosing a format?
Yes. The cover and the first chapter are free to read before anything is paid for or printed, and the format is chosen after that - so the binding is the last decision rather than the first.
Other guides
Last updated:
Decide by who will be holding it in three years. Everything else about this question was written for somebody else’s book.
Browse the collection